[Boost-announce] Review Conclusion - Futures Library
Review Conclusion - Futures Library Braddock Gaskill http://braddock.com/~braddock/future Anthony Williams http://www.justsoftwaresolutions.co.uk/files/n2561_future.hpp The lack of examples and documentation made them difficult to review. Nevertheless, Anthony Williams futures library did receive almost unanimous and enthusiastic support. Unfortunately, the depth of the support was very shallow. I just finished my first read of Anthony's book "C++ Concurrency in Action and acknowledge his expertise in the areas of multi threaded and parallel programming. (http://www.manning.com/williams/) Anthony is the maintainer of boost::threads. Anthony's Future library has been approved for the next major release of c++ standard. Conclusion Braddock Gaskill - Rejected Anthony Williams - Approved Anthony's Futures library is approved for inclusion into boost::threads. As he is the maintainer of that library, he should be given maximum latitude about how that is to be done. In the future, if Anthony wants to re-publish the library as a top-level boost library, then he needs to resubmit it again with samples and test cases, which are lacking. Requirements As per the usual boost library requirements, examples and test cases are needed. Anthony should also improve the documentation, which should not be a problem as he is a prolific author in the area of multi threaded programming. Review Manager Tom Brinkman _______________________________________________ Unsubscribe & other changes: http://lists.boost.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/boost-announce
Is that all there is to Williams's library; a single header file? Nothing else? -Sid -----Original Message----- From: boost-bounces@lists.boost.org [mailto:boost-bounces@lists.boost.org] On Behalf Of Tom Brinkman Sent: Tuesday, April 21, 2009 12:31 AM To: boost-announce@lists.boost.org Subject: [boost] [Boost-announce] Review Conclusion - Futures Library Review Conclusion - Futures Library Braddock Gaskill http://braddock.com/~braddock/future Anthony Williams http://www.justsoftwaresolutions.co.uk/files/n2561_future.hpp Review Manager Tom Brinkman
Hi, ----- Original Message ----- From: "Tom Brinkman" <reportbase@gmail.com> To: <boost-announce@lists.boost.org> Sent: Tuesday, April 21, 2009 6:30 AM Subject: [boost] [Boost-announce] Review Conclusion - Futures Library
Review Conclusion - Futures Library
Braddock Gaskill http://braddock.com/~braddock/future
Anthony Williams http://www.justsoftwaresolutions.co.uk/files/n2561_future.hpp
The lack of examples and documentation made them difficult to review. Nevertheless, Anthony Williams futures library did receive almost unanimous and enthusiastic support. Unfortunately, the depth of the support was very shallow.
I just finished my first read of Anthony's book "C++ Concurrency in Action and acknowledge his expertise in the areas of multi threaded and parallel programming. (http://www.manning.com/williams/)
Anthony is the maintainer of boost::threads.
Anthony's Future library has been approved for the next major release of c++ standard.
Conclusion
Braddock Gaskill - Rejected Anthony Williams - Approved
This is an excellent new.
Anthony's Futures library is approved for inclusion into boost::threads. As he is the maintainer of that library, he should be given maximum latitude about how that is to be done.
Anthony, I would like to know which issues, proposals from the review would you take in account. Could you send to this ML a summary?
In the future, if Anthony wants to re-publish the library as a top-level boost library, then he needs to resubmit it again with samples and test cases, which are lacking.
I don't see the need, but ...
Requirements
As per the usual boost library requirements, examples and test cases are needed. Anthony should also improve the documentation, which should not be a problem as he is a prolific author in the area of multi threaded programming.
Congratulations Anthony, Vicente
participants (3)
-
Sid Sacek -
Tom Brinkman -
vicente.botet