Hello Alexander, I'm sorry, but that page is just a sample page. Bjarne's article is not an official posting. We haven't launched yet. If you want to discuss the content of Bjarne's comments, you can email him directly, but it has nothing to do with The C++ Source. Sorry if I didn't make it clear that that page was just a sample. I meant to. Saturday, June 12, 2004, 11:01:35 AM, you wrote: brlbo> Chuck Allison wrote: brlbo> [...]

...

viewing at http://www.artima.com/cppsource. The idea is to have

brlbo> Quoting from http://www.artima.com/intv/elegance.html. Few comments brlbo> follow. brlbo> <quote author=Bjarne Stroustrup> brlbo> I don't put in specific features for concurrency, because you can put brlbo> them in a library. brlbo> </quote> brlbo> You can't do that without threaded memory model, to begin with. brlbo> <quote> brlbo> C was designed with the principle that you should be able to write brlbo> its standard library in the language itself. That same principle brlbo> guided the design of C++. brlbo> </quote> brlbo> Show me the the standard C++ impl of atomic<> for a rather simple brlbo> thing like brlbo> class swap_based_mutex_for_windows { // noncopyable brlbo> atomic<int> m_lock_status; // 0: free, 1/-1: locked/contention brlbo> auto_reset_event m_retry_event; // "slow" bin sema/gate brlbo> public: brlbo> // ctor/dtor [w/o lazy event init] brlbo> void lock() throw() { brlbo> if (m_lock_status.swap(1, msync::acq)) brlbo> while (m_lock_status.swap(-1, msync::acq)) brlbo> m_retry_event.wait(); brlbo> } brlbo> bool trylock() throw() { brlbo> return !m_lock_status.swap(1, msync::acq) ? brlbo> true : !m_lock_status.swap(-1, msync::acq); brlbo> } brlbo> bool timedlock(absolute_timeout const & timeout) throw() { brlbo> if (m_lock_status.swap(1, msync::acq)) { brlbo> while (m_lock_status.swap(-1, msync::acq)) brlbo> if (!m_retry_event.timedwait(timeout)) brlbo> return false; brlbo> } brlbo> return true; brlbo> } brlbo> void unlock() throw() { brlbo> if (m_lock_status.swap(0, msync::rel) < 0) brlbo> m_retry_event.set(); brlbo> } brlbo> }; brlbo> regards, brlbo> alexander. -- Best regards, Chuck