boost::optional can be used for many purposes. One of these (and I had to use optional like that) is to make classes that provide RAII-like interface (noncopyable, nonmoveable) usable in contexts where I need to use two-phase initialization or to release the resource before the end of the scope (subject to some runtime condition) -- all that in order to have a resource acquired for as short span of time as possible. I would be forced to do that for std::lock_guard if the library did not provide a second template std::unique_lock. But not every library provides two interfaces for almost the same thing, and this is arguably an unnecessary redundancy for an interface. optional<RAII> as described above is a generic tool for transforming types that implement 'scoped ownership' into types that implement 'unique ownership' of a resource.

I think I went too far with this story. Although you can implement a two-phase initialization and cleanup, you cannot provide a full 'unique ownership' semantics with boost::optional for 'scoped' types, because there is no way to implement a move constructor for types that do not support either a move constructor or swap. Regards, &rzej