"Peter Dimov" <pdimov@mmltd.net> writes:
Fredrik Blomqvist wrote:
Hi
Consider this example of mem_fn usage:
struct X { int bar; }; std::vector<X> vec; .... boost::make_transform_iterator(vec.begin(), boost::mem_fn(&X::bar));
The above is, strictly speaking, _not_ a Random Access Traversal Iterator, or even a Forward Traversal Iterator, and would fail in otherwise concept conforming code (or in a potential concept-check).
The problems lies in the function objects returned by boost::mem_fn and boost::bind not being default constructible, thus making the resulting iterator not default constructible which is required by the Forward Traversal concept.
No, the problem lies in (the current implementation of) transform_iterator. It is not reasonable to require function objects to be default constructible, because few of them are, and in fact, the documentation places no such requirement on the function object.
Good point. We should use boost::optional here. Patches welcomed! -- Dave Abrahams Boost Consulting http://www.boost-consulting.com