1 Jun
2005
1 Jun
'05
8:28 p.m.
Andy Little wrote:
Three positive reviews is not sufficient in my opinion. However, the precedent has already be set, as other libraries have been approved on a similar limited number of reviews.
Obvious questions in response to this... How many reviews are sufficient? What proportion in favour/against acceptance is acceptable?
The judgement of the library's review manager is the final determinent. The criteria that he/she used to accept or reject the submission should be clearly stated in the review managers report after the review period is over. Tom Brinkman