John Torjo <john.lists@torjo.com> writes:
I take back "Accepted by default", since is a bit confusing, sorry for that.
Here's what I mean: it's clear that people want such a library, and a lot of positive feedback was received. I know the library cannot be accepted at this time.
I think the review process is close to as good as it can practically expected to be. In this particular case, I think that to small things sort of clouded the issue. a) The reference to the "vote" which over emphasizes the "voting" aspect. In the future I think it would be better to use the term "recommend" b) the "Accepted by default", I think this particular situation could have been handled better with "the library is not accepted at this time" reasons.... Robert Ramey