On Sat, Feb 1, 2025 at 1:36 PM John Maddock wrote:
First off I'd like to thank Matt and Chris for submitting the library for review, and for all the reviewers who submitted comments. My apologies for not posting this sooner, but this has been a difficult review to reach a definite result on.
First the headline result: the result of the review is INDETERMINATE.
What this means in practice: I'd like to encourage Matt and Chris to come back for a mini-review at a later date which should focus exclusively on the open issues listed below. I forget which library we applied this to in the past, but I believe the result is not without precedent.
Thank you John for managing the review, and thank you to Matt and Chris for your (clearly very hard) work on the library. I am looking forward to a future revision of the library that I could be enthusiastic about, and that would grace Boost by its inclusion. Glen