On Wed, Sep 11, 2024 at 6:04 AM Andrzej Krzemienski via Boost
If one feels one got a green light from LEWG that one's library will be accepted into STD, the motivation for putting it into Boost diminishes. Here, I do not think we will be able to do much.
Inbal Levi is a member of the Boost Foundation Board of Directors. She is also the chair of LEWG. Every library-only proposal for C++ (including std::execution) must go through LEWG first. LEWG could simply adopt as a policy, that any library-only proposal must already be published as a library, for a minimum period of time, and having acquired users and integration in other public projects. This doesn't mean it has to be accepted into Boost first, although that is an option. The "green light from LEWG" could be changed to a red light. My personal opinion is that if the only thing that LEWG did was to reject all pure library proposals for ten years, C++ would be improved. Thanks