Hi Gregory, GC is an approach at solving resources management. It works very well in many cases. As you seem to be versed in the area, you also know that it can go horribly wrong resulting in terrible performances and massive memory usage. These cases must be debugged and take a lot of time and can hit you very late in project (read: when switching to production). GC will not prevent you from correctly designing your project and being careful with resource management. A GC is a program, and as such, has to be correctly used to function properly. There is no "magic". You still need to plan in advance, be rigorous and anticipate the bandwidth. RAII and smart pointers are a different approach at resources management. It works very well in many cases. Like a GC, it needs to be used correctly to function properly.
This approach obviously works, and is simple for toy cases like this. It becomes quite a bit less simple in real software. Yes, every software design should be capable of being broken up in such a way. But sometimes doing so is pure hell on your interface encapsulation, or comes with highly nontrivial costs, or maybe you'd rather use the GC to accomplish the same task in 1 month instead of 4 months so you can spend more of your time on stuff your customer actually cares about.
I would like to be presented with a C++ project that takes 1 month with a GC, 4 months with RAII. Most surprising. Not to say I encountered every possible projects in my life, but I'm extremely surprised. I've worked on many different projects and every time I had a resource management issue, with garbage collected languages it took a different form, but nevertheless, it occurred.
I'm not going to dispute that it's always possible to design good software packages without a GC, and I think that you should always consider non-GC designs first (not that we have much of a choice in C++ at this point, which is the problem under discussion.) But especially for prototypes where proving algorithm feasibility is more important than clean design, or in the real world where we don't have unlimited time to develop and deliver our software using developers who aren't necessarily C++ programming gods, a GC could make life much easier by ensuring that we could rely on "good enough" automated memory management.
C++ is not a silver bullet and maybe your solution needs to be implemented with a different tool. Kind regards. -- Edouard Alligand Partner Bureau 14 SARL - http://www.bureau14.fr/