"Robert Mathews" <rmathews@envoyww.com> writes:
I'm glad to see this thread starting, I definitely think this is a good idea.
"David Abrahams" <dave@boost-consulting.com> wrote in message news:uoeay3md4.fsf@boost-consulting.com...
"Pablo Aguilar" <pablo.aguilar@gmail.com> writes:
I believe that detecting which libraries need building would just be a matter of searching for a "build" subdirectory within a given library's directory.
Yep.
Don't know about configurations, though, maybe some simple parsing of the jamfiles would do..
Don't try to parse Jamfiles. It will be fragile at best and a disaster at worst. Think of Jamfile contents like C++ source code; you want a real C++ compiler in order to process that and make any sense of it. For Jamfiles you want to do any understanding within Boost.Build.
As far as JAM interacting with the installer program, why don't you have boost.JAM build the installation program?
Well, that's the right idea... but why don't YOU have boost.Jam build the installation program? ;-) Lots of great ideas going around here, but we need people willing to do the work that makes the difference.
That way this installer isn't a red-haired bastard stepchild, but just another target in the Boost.build environment. Boost.build is certainly powerful enough!
Basically, I'd add a target after "install" that could grab the source and built libraries and feed those files into the installer script, creating a single installer output file (say, "boost_1.32.msi"). Then the boost maintainers could publish just that file on the web.
The reason I chose not to do it as an installer, is because I'm far more comfortable with developing GUIs with say, BCB, than I am with the installer programs I've tried.
Well .. the commercial installers take care of a lot of common issues that occur, adding a layer of reliability and tested code for the common tasks of installing files, editing paths, registry, and displaying a familar user interface. Are you really sure you'd want to stray off the beaten path here?
I wouldn't. -- Dave Abrahams Boost Consulting www.boost-consulting.com