Re: [boost] Request for a "Policy Review" regarding 'CMakeLists.txt'

On 5/17/16 9:33 AM, Rene Rivera wrote:

On Tue, May 17, 2016 at 11:29 AM, Paul Fultz II wrote:

...

Cmake doesn't impose a layout, and that's the whole point. I clone hana and then call `cmake hana` to build it using cmake. Imposing a layout such as hiding it in some unknown directory just causes confusion.

As a not-cmake-user I don't know what you mean there. What commands do you invoke, precisely?

As one who spend a fair amount of time with different ways to use CMake I found that the best way to using in a setup like boost is a) Put CMakeLists.txt files in subdirectories like src, test, example, doc, example b) Put a minimal CMakeLists.txt file in parent directory which includes common things liket setup etc. The top level includes sub directories. So it can (and in my view) should be fairly small. Used in this way, it's quite like boost build in it's way of doing things. It does take special care to be permit the building of part of the project - something boost build handles very well. I think many users of CMake fall in the trap of making the top level as centralized system which in short order becomes too complex to understand - like putting behavior in base class which should have been placed in a derived class. But this has to be handled on a case by case basis as CMake itself is very haphazard system. Robert Ramey