Tom Brinkman wrote:
Thank you! With all due respect to Dr. Reese, I think posting a review and then asking to be emailed for replies is not right. The review is a public affair. We would also like to read about the replies and exchanges that ensue after a reviewer posts his review. A reviewer should also be responsible to answer and reply to the questions and answers related to his review _on_list_ in as much as the one being reviewed (Lubomir et. al.) tries as best as they can to answer and reply to the reviews. It's not a one way street.
Ok, I kinda agree. However, there may have be a reason that they were not able to. Not shur why that would be, but in any case I told him that he could email me the review if he was unable to post it the group himself. In the future, I'll be firmer and polightly insist that they try join the mailing list.
Understood. Thanks! Regards, -- Joel de Guzman http://www.boost-consulting.com http://spirit.sf.net