Aaron W. LaFramboise wrote:
Michael Glassford wrote:
Aaron W. LaFramboise wrote:
Michael Glassford wrote:
Aaron W. LaFramboise wrote:
Following is an implementation of, and some comments on, a staticly linked Boost.Thread thread exit handler for MSVC.
By the way, I appologize for talking so long to cough this up after posting teasing remarks about this months ago. Programming is presently a hobby and volunteer work for me, unfortunately.
Thanks! I've been looking forward to you posting this, and it appears to work beautifully for VC++ 7.1 (as others have already commented). Do I have your permission to included it in Boost.Threads under the Boost license (with your name on it, of course)?
Yes, you and anyone else have perpetual permission to offer it under any license you choose.
Thank you. It's in, and will be in the upcoming release. A lot of people will be happy, including me! I look forward to the GCC version as well, though I haven't yet used GCC myself.
Make sure you look at Roland's code that gets MSVC6 right by doing a fixup that fixes a problem in the TLS support code. That fixup should only be done on MSVC6 though.
I definitely will. I was under the impression that it was still under construction, but if it's ready, I'm interested.
For GCC/MinGW, I'm actually adding an API that gets all of this right: an atexit variant that knows about module unloading and thread destruction. Ideally all compilers would have such an API to make these sorts of problems easy. :)
If I understand what DLL_PROCESS_DETACH means (the thread is being notified that it is being detached because the process is exiting), the call to on_process_exit() is incorrect; on_process_exit() is meant to be called when the process actually exits (it calls TlsFree()). The most likely place to call it is at the end of main() or after the main thread exits.
Well, as near as I can tell, when the TLS routine is called with DLL_PROCESS_DETACH, this will be the absolute last user code executing in the process, including DLL destructors. As far as I know, once you return from DLL_PROCESS_DETACH in the TLS routine, no more user code will run.
Is it called only for the last thread to detach, or can it be called for more than one thread? Does it work the same for tls_callback and DllMain? Mike