Gevorg Voskanyan wrote:

Roland Bock wrote:

...

Hi,

a week ago, Vladimir wrote that a formal review of boost.log would start this week. Did I miss the formal mail?

Thanks and regards,

Roland

It was announced on developer's list yesterday:

http://lists.boost.org/Archives/boost/2010/03/162759.php

Regards, Gevorg

Thanks :-) I am on boost-users only (some reviews are announced here, too). I guess it is still OK to send review results to the boost-users-list (the review mail indicates that the developers list is the only valid address)? Regards, Roland

Though I certainly can't give an authoritative answer on that matter, I do vaguely remember some complaints being raised in the past on reviews being sent to users list. Also, this list's info page, http://lists.boost.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/boost-users, seems to suggest that boost-devel is the more appropriate place to submit library reviews: "This list is for discussion of issues related to using these libraries. [...] If your interest is in library submission, development, or review, please subscribe to the Boost developer list."

But as I already said, this response is in no way an authoritative one, so please don't take my word for that!

HTH,

Regards, Gevorg

Gevorg, thanks! It has been some time since I last read the list's description. I'll probably subscribe to the developers list, too, if only for reviewing this library which I consider too important not to be reviewed :-) Regards, Roland

Roland Bock writes:

Gevorg Voskanyan wrote:

...

Roland Bock wrote:

...

Hi,

a week ago, Vladimir wrote that a formal review of boost.log would start

this

...

...

week. Did I miss the formal mail?

Thanks and regards,

Roland

It was announced on developer's list yesterday:

http://lists.boost.org/Archives/boost/2010/03/162759.php

Regards, Gevorg

Thanks

I am on boost-users only (some reviews are announced here, too). I guess it is still OK to send review results to the boost-users-list (the review mail indicates that the developers list is the only valid address)?

Roland, please feel free to post your review on the Boosr.Users list. Normally reviews get announced here as well, but for some reason this didn't happen this time. We are always very interested in getting feedback from the widest possible audience, so restricting reviews to the developers list wouldn't make any sense. Regards Hartmut --------------- Meet me at BoostCon www.boostcon.com