Boosters, the formal review of the Boost.DLL library by Antony Polukhin is now finished. The preliminary results are as follows: The following people have provided reviews: - Ralf Globisch - Yes - Klaim - Joël Lamotte - Yes (*) - Niall Douglas - Yes, conditionally - John P Fletcher - Yes - Bjorn Reese - Yes - Edward Diener - Yes Klaim - Joël has asked that his vote is not counted until he's done trying the library for real, and there was no confirmation it's done yet. The following people have contributed, but did not provide a review - Rodrigo Madera - Thomas Trummer - Rob Stewart - Ion Gaztañaga If anybody would like to amend or clarify anything, or plans to provide additional comments during this week, please contact me off-list. I will post final review result after that. Thanks, Volodya
Hi Vladimir, you did not count the positive review of Rodrigo Madera :-) http://lists.boost.org/boost-users/2015/07/84546.php Best, Johannes
On 14-Jul-15 11:21 AM, Johannes wrote:
Hi Vladimir,
you did not count the positive review of Rodrigo Madera :-)
Johannes, indeed - the review was posted only to boost-users, so I've missed it. Thanks for noticing! - Volodya
On Tue, Jul 14, 2015 at 6:53 AM, Vladimir Prus <vladimir.prus@gmail.com> wrote:
On 14-Jul-15 11:21 AM, Johannes wrote:
Hi Vladimir,
you did not count the positive review of Rodrigo Madera :-)
Thanks, Johannes! I was about to send that. indeed - the review was posted only to boost-users, so I've missed it.
Thanks for noticing!
- Volodya
My blunder. I just replied over your message without noticing. Regards, Rodrigo Madera
On 14 July 2015 at 09:59, Vladimir Prus <vladimir.prus@gmail.com> wrote:
(Klaim - ) Joël has asked that his vote is not counted until he's done trying the library for real, and there was no confirmation it's done yet.
To complete that: I progressed but still didn't completely finish but so far didn't hit any issue or anything bothering me. So as there is no "no-go" point for me at this point, I can confirm my YES vote.
On 14-Jul-15 2:15 PM, Klaim - Joël Lamotte wrote:
On 14 July 2015 at 09:59, Vladimir Prus <vladimir.prus@gmail.com <mailto:vladimir.prus@gmail.com>> wrote:
(Klaim - ) Joël has asked that his vote is not counted until he's done trying the library for real, and there was no confirmation it's done yet.
To complete that: I progressed but still didn't completely finish but so far didn't hit any issue or anything bothering me. So as there is no "no-go" point for me at this point, I can confirm my YES vote.
Thanks! - Volodya
participants (4)
-
Johannes -
Klaim - Joël Lamotte -
Rodrigo Madera -
Vladimir Prus