boost::function/boost::bind compilation error
Hi,
I was trying to use boost function/bind to bind the first argument of a member function that takes two arguments, when I got into a compilation error that I can't quite decipher or understand, below is a sample representation of the problem, and then there's the compilation error, am I doing something incorrectly here?
I have tried removing the boost::mem_fn instantiation with no difference.
#include
On Sun, Sep 6, 2009 at 1:23 AM, Ahmed Badran
Hi,
I was trying to use boost function/bind to bind the first argument of a member function that takes two arguments, when I got into a compilation error that I can't quite decipher or understand, below is a sample representation of the problem, and then there's the compilation error, am I doing something incorrectly here?
I have tried removing the boost::mem_fn instantiation with no difference.
#include
#include #include #include <iostream> using namespace std; using namespace boost;
class my_class { public: void test(bool b) { cout << "got " << b << endl; } private: };
int main() { my_class c; boost::function1
test_fn; boost::bind(&my_class::test, &c, _2); /* causes a compilation error */ test_fn = boost::bind<void>(boost::mem_fn(&my_class::test), &c, _2);
Don't need the mem_fn here - and the _2 should be _1 as well, as you've declared test_fn with 1 parameter, so use this: test_fn = boost::bind(&my_class::test, &c, _1);
/* works fine */ test_fn = bind1st(mem_fun(&my_class::test), &c);
test_fn(true); test_fn(false); return 0; }
<snip>
Regards, Ahmed
Stuart Dootson
AMDG Ahmed Badran wrote:
I was trying to use boost function/bind to bind the first argument of a member function that takes two arguments, when I got into a compilation error that I can't quite decipher or understand, below is a sample representation of the problem, and then there's the compilation error, am I doing something incorrectly here?
I have tried removing the boost::mem_fn instantiation with no difference.
#include
#include #include #include <iostream> using namespace std; using namespace boost;
class my_class { public: void test(bool b) { cout << "got " << b << endl; } private: };
int main() { my_class c; boost::function1
test_fn; boost::bind(&my_class::test, &c, _2); /* causes a compilation error */ test_fn = boost::bind<void>(boost::mem_fn(&my_class::test), &c, _2);
Use _1 instead of _2. The placeholder number indicates the first argument to the function object created by bind. You're only passing a single bool argument in, so only _1 is a valid placeholder. In Christ, Steven Watanabe
Steven Watanabe wrote:
AMDG
Ahmed Badran wrote:
I was trying to use boost function/bind to bind the first argument of a member function that takes two arguments, when I got into a compilation error that I can't quite decipher or understand, below is a sample representation of the problem, and then there's the compilation error, am I doing something incorrectly here?
I have tried removing the boost::mem_fn instantiation with no difference.
#include
#include #include #include <iostream> using namespace std; using namespace boost;
class my_class { public: void test(bool b) { cout << "got " << b << endl; } private: };
int main() { my_class c; boost::function1
test_fn; boost::bind(&my_class::test, &c, _2); /* causes a compilation error */ test_fn = boost::bind<void>(boost::mem_fn(&my_class::test), &c, _2);
Use _1 instead of _2. The placeholder number indicates the first argument to the function object created by bind. You're only passing a single bool argument in, so only _1 is a valid placeholder.
Thanks, for some reason I thought, the function originally takes two and since I'm binding the first, I want to let the second pass through, the documentation also has "The placeholder _N selects the argument at position N from the argument list passed at "call time."" But since I wasn't calling it then and there, I somehow seemed to skip it. So the _N is essentially the positional parameter of the output function from bind rather than the input function. Thanks again. -Ahmed
participants (3)
-
Ahmed Badran
-
Steven Watanabe
-
Stuart Dootson