data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cfc05/cfc054df941ef79f7d776ad1c3b4bd8df863f1ae" alt=""
Hi, what kind of object does boost::bind return when binding to a class member variable ? (as opposed to a member method). Is it a function object too? More in particular, I would like to write a generic free function that applies an operation on a particular member variable, passed in with boost::bind. Something like this: struct A { int value; }; void f(bind_return_type& membervar) { membervar = 3; } A a; f(bind(&A::value, a)); Thanks. --nico -- nico galoppo von borries | address: 105 creel st., chapel hill comp. graphics phd. student | north carolina, 27516 USA UNC, chapel hill | phone: +1 (919) 962-1898 (office) | +1 (919) 942-7609 (home) | email: nico at cs dot unc dot edu | homepage: http://www.ngaloppo.org
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a2580/a25808999b7a6c2225cddb98eb94d17185c613c6" alt=""
On 3/29/06, Nico Galoppo
Hi,
what kind of object does boost::bind return when binding to a class member variable ? (as opposed to a member method). Is it a function object too?
More in particular, I would like to write a generic free function that applies an operation on a particular member variable, passed in with boost::bind. Something like this:
struct A { int value; };
void f(bind_return_type& membervar) { membervar = 3; }
A a; f(bind(&A::value, a));
Thanks.
--nico
Couldn't you just do void f(int& membervar) { membervar = 3; } A a; f(a.value); ? To get back to bind return types - they're not simple. Your best bet is to use boost::function to hold the result of boost::bind if you want to keep it around. Just make sure any variables involved are still alive when the function is eventually invoked. Stuart Dootson
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cfc05/cfc054df941ef79f7d776ad1c3b4bd8df863f1ae" alt=""
Hi Stuart, thanks for your answer. Stuart Dootson wrote:
void f(int& membervar) { membervar = 3; }
A a; f(a.value);
Well, I probably over-simplified the problem. What I would really like to do is manipulate data members of all instances in a container, where the data member is given as an input parameter. struct A { int value; int othervalue; } container<A> array; void f(container<A> & array, membervarref) { BOOST_FOREACH(container<A>::value_type& element, array) bind(membervarref, element) = 3; } f(array, &A::value); f(array, &A::othervalue); --nico -- nico galoppo von borries @ address: 105 creel st., chapel hill comp. graphics phd. student @ north carolina, 27516 USA UNC, chapel hill @ phone: +1 (919) 962-1898 (office) @ +1 (919) 942-7609 (home) @ email: nico at cs dot unc dot edu @ homepage: http://www.cs.unc.edu/~nico --- debian linux :: vim powered
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a2580/a25808999b7a6c2225cddb98eb94d17185c613c6" alt=""
On 3/30/06, Nico Galoppo
Well, I probably over-simplified the problem. What I would really like to do is manipulate data members of all instances in a container, where the data member is given as an input parameter.
struct A { int value; int othervalue; }
container<A> array;
void f(container<A> & array, membervarref) { BOOST_FOREACH(container<A>::value_type& element, array) bind(membervarref, element) = 3; }
f(array, &A::value); f(array, &A::othervalue);
--nico
Well, how about this (using you definition of A):
typedef std::vector<A> As;
typedef int A::*Setter;
void Set(As& as, Setter setter, int value)
{
using namespace boost::lambda;
std::for_each(as.begin(), as.end(), bind(setter, _1) = value);
}
void func()
{
As as;
Set(as, &A::a, 3);
Set(as, &A::b, 5);
}
If you want to decouple from A a bit more, you could change the
definition of Setter like below
typedef boost::function
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cfc05/cfc054df941ef79f7d776ad1c3b4bd8df863f1ae" alt=""
Hi Stuart, thanks for the solution. It seems like what I am looking for, I'll try it out asap. However, I am confused by the typedef below. typedef int A::*Setter; Could you explain what is going on here? --nico Stuart Dootson wrote:
On 3/30/06, Nico Galoppo
wrote: <snip> Well, I probably over-simplified the problem. What I would really like to do is manipulate data members of all instances in a container, where the data member is given as an input parameter.
struct A { int value; int othervalue; }
container<A> array;
void f(container<A> & array, membervarref) { BOOST_FOREACH(container<A>::value_type& element, array) bind(membervarref, element) = 3; }
f(array, &A::value); f(array, &A::othervalue);
--nico
Well, how about this (using you definition of A):
typedef std::vector<A> As; typedef int A::*Setter;
void Set(As& as, Setter setter, int value) { using namespace boost::lambda; std::for_each(as.begin(), as.end(), bind(setter, _1) = value); }
void func() { As as;
Set(as, &A::a, 3); Set(as, &A::b, 5); }
If you want to decouple from A a bit more, you could change the definition of Setter like below
typedef boost::function
Setter; and it'll compile and run OK (tested with VC7.1).
Stuart Dootson _______________________________________________ Boost-users mailing list Boost-users@lists.boost.org http://lists.boost.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/boost-users
-- nico galoppo von borries @ address: 105 creel st., chapel hill comp. graphics phd. student @ north carolina, 27516 USA UNC, chapel hill @ phone: +1 (919) 962-1898 (office) @ +1 (919) 942-7609 (home) @ email: nico at cs dot unc dot edu @ homepage: http://www.cs.unc.edu/~nico --- debian linux :: vim powered
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3b660/3b6606c2b4d7e319cdf2a8c6039a458c14e83916" alt=""
Nico Galoppo wrote:
Hi Stuart,
thanks for the solution. It seems like what I am looking for, I'll try it out asap. However, I am confused by the typedef below.
typedef int A::*Setter;
Could you explain what is going on here?
It defines Setter to be an alias for the type "pointer to 'integer member of A'". Sebastian Redl
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cfc05/cfc054df941ef79f7d776ad1c3b4bd8df863f1ae" alt=""
Thanks Mathias! Do you have an example of how that would work? I have no experience with boost::any. --nico loufoque wrote:
Stuart Dootson wrote :
Well, how about this (using you definition of A):
typedef std::vector<A> As; typedef int A::*Setter;
[...]
Such a solution only works if all member variables are ints. If it needs to work with any type, boost::any could be used.
_______________________________________________ Boost-users mailing list Boost-users@lists.boost.org http://lists.boost.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/boost-users
-- nico galoppo von borries | address: 105 creel st., chapel hill comp. graphics phd. student | north carolina, 27516 USA UNC, chapel hill | phone: +1 (919) 962-1898 (office) | +1 (919) 942-7609 (home) | email: nico at cs dot unc dot edu | homepage: http://www.ngaloppo.org
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/23b47/23b47402ea8bd75ed10e7b2ecf66648bbe18d2ef" alt=""
Nico Galoppo wrote:
Do you have an example of how that would work? I have no experience with boost::any.
It was just an idea actually, and not a very good one : I couldn't even
make it work.
I'm just discovering boost::any myself and I thought you could bind on
it automagically.
Using templates is simpler.
template
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3b660/3b6606c2b4d7e319cdf2a8c6039a458c14e83916" alt=""
Nico Galoppo wrote:
Hi,
what kind of object does boost::bind return when binding to a class member variable ? (as opposed to a member method). Is it a function object too?
Yes, the result is an unary function object, the parameter being the object to retrieve the variable of, and which returns a reference to the member variable. The exact type of course is a complicated bind expression, so a non-template is not particularly suited for taking it. Sebastian Redl
participants (4)
-
loufoque
-
Nico Galoppo
-
Sebastian Redl
-
Stuart Dootson