It seems that bundled properties still don't work with subgraphs. I found a mention of the problem dating back to 2005 [1], a closed ticket for the issue [2] and another post [3], this time from 2008, with an ex tempore fix (which doesn't work for me). Could someone possibly account for that?

[1] http://lists.boost.org/boost-users/2005/03/10844.php [2] https://svn.boost.org/trac/boost/ticket/380 [3] http://www.nabble.com/-graph--property_map-from-bundled-properties-in-a-subg...

If I had to guess, I would say that there aren't very many people using subgraph so it's implementation hasn't evolved with the rest of the library. That's probably true of a lot of BGL code. How quickly do you need a fix? I'm pretty busy for the next week of so, but I might be able to make some time this weekend. Andrew Sutton andrew.n.sutton@gmail.com

It seems that bundled properties still don't work with subgraphs. I found a mention of the problem dating back to 2005 [1], a closed ticket for the issue [2] and another post [3], this time from 2008, with an ex tempore fix (which doesn't work for me). Could someone possibly account for that?

[1] http://lists.boost.org/boost-users/2005/03/10844.php [2] https://svn.boost.org/trac/boost/ticket/380 [3] http://www.nabble.com/-graph--property_map-from-bundled-properties-in-a-subg...

TIA, Greg Slodkowicz

I applied the patch from Dmitry and added a new test file for subgraphs with bundled properties and everything seems to work just fine in trunk. There are some caveats, of course. 1. Subraphs require interior index properties for both vertices and edges, and no adjacency list provides both of these by default. You get vertex indices with VertexSet == vecS, but that's about it. You have to modify the properties of the *underlying* adjacency list - not just the subgraph. For example: // Define the edge property struct my_edge { ... }; typedef property edge_prop; // Define the underlying graph and the subgraph typedef adjacency_list Graph; typedef subgraph<Graph> Subgraph; 2. This may not fully solve your problem since simply providing indices doesn't mean that they're going to be used. You may need to explicitly set the index of each vertex or edge during graph construction. If you remove vertices or edges... well, that doesn't seem to be a well explored operation with subgraphs. 3. Property maps are accessed from the subgraph: Subgraph sg; typedef property_map::type WeightMap; WeightMap weights = get(&my_edge::weight, sg); Boost 1.38.0 release branch is closed, so this won't appear in the release until 1.39. Andrew Sutton andrew.n.sutton@gmail.com