RE: [Boost-users] Re: License compatibility issues.
David Abrahams wrote:
It seems to me that we can't ask our volunteer lawyers to draw up a list of answers to all the possible licensing questions along these lines, nor can we reasonably make them available as an on-demand resource for answering boost users' legal questions. No, but I think that the interaction between the LGPL or GPL and the Boost License is probably going to be a very frequently encountered scenario. Basically, what it boils down to is: what is the compatibility between LGPL or GPL, and the Boost license?
Can we draw up a list of the most common free-software licenses, say the top three, and ask the volunteer lawyers to determine whether Boost is compatible with each of the three? I don't mean to determine the various combinations and permutations, e.g. Boost and GPL and Mozilla Artistic, but the simple ones: Boost and "x", Boost and "y", etc. Until and unless such a comparison is done, though, I would echo your advice about seeking a competent legal opinion. -- Jim Hyslop Senior Software Designer Leitch Technology International Inc. (http://www.leitch.com) Columnist, C/C++ Users Journal (http://www.cuj.com/experts)
"Jim.Hyslop"
David Abrahams wrote:
It seems to me that we can't ask our volunteer lawyers to draw up a list of answers to all the possible licensing questions along these lines, nor can we reasonably make them available as an on-demand resource for answering boost users' legal questions.
No, but I think that the interaction between the LGPL or GPL and the Boost License is probably going to be a very frequently encountered scenario. Basically, what it boils down to is: what is the compatibility between LGPL or GPL, and the Boost license?
There are lots of different possible interactions, depending on what code (Boost or [L]GPL) they want to ship as source vs. compiled... and who knows what other issues become relevant.
Can we draw up a list of the most common free-software licenses, say the top three, and ask the volunteer lawyers to determine whether Boost is compatible with each of the three? I don't mean to determine the various combinations and permutations, e.g. Boost and GPL and Mozilla Artistic, but the simple ones: Boost and "x", Boost and "y", etc.
We could try, but as I've said there are quite a few scenarios. If you can identify a specific list of the important ones, with all the important details (and I'm not even sure what they are) filled in, we can try to get the lawyers to comment on them.
Until and unless such a comparison is done, though, I would echo your advice about seeking a competent legal opinion.
-- Dave Abrahams Boost Consulting www.boost-consulting.com
participants (2)
-
David Abrahams -
Jim.Hyslop