Re: boost::lexical_cast string to string problem

I'm seeing a problem with lexical_cast. The following code when

--- In Boost-Users@y..., "Jason Fischl" wrote: trying to

convert from string to string fails when passed an empty string. The library code that is doing this lexical_cast does not and can not know that the input and output types are the same.

I believe that this code should not throw.

#include <iostream> #include

main() { std::string input(""); try { boost::lexical_caststd::string(input); } catch (boost::bad_lexical_cast& e) { std::cout << "Failed" << std::endl; } }

Since one can't partially specialise function templates, one way to do it could be that the library included something like this: namespace boost { template<> std::string lexical_caststd::string,std::string(std::string arg) { return arg; } template<> std::string lexical_cast(const char *arg) { return arg; } template<> std::string lexical_cast(char *arg) { return arg; } } This is quite brittle, though, as it only works for the types given. It does work for your example, for Intel C++ and VC++, though (the compilers I've tested it with). If partial specialisation was possible, you could do: namespace boost { template<class T> T lexical_cast(T arg) { return arg; } } Interestingly, the person behind lexical_cast, Kevlin Henney, is on the standards committee, and in this case, a language change could help his library. :) Regards, Terje