Hartmut Kaiser wrote:
In general, the review was valuable for what it accomplished. It moved us closer towards a unified Boost library in the domain of functional programming idioms. Thanks to Joel and Dan for the high quality submission and to all participating the discussion for their valuable insights!
Thank you Hartmut for managing the review. Thank you all who participated in the review, those who joined in the discussions, and especially those who gave full reviews. It was a very fruitful 2 weeks. It's a good chance to learn more about what the community wants. As Hartmut says, it's more about the future than the past and present. Indeed, that's how I envisioned the review. Regardless of the outcome, I was determined to improve Phoenix. As with Spirit and Fusion, it's a work of love. It's very encouraging to see that it has now become an official Boost library, after many years as a sub-library under Spirit. I did believe that it merited the Boost status. I also knew that the review will be tough due to it's unique position in the midst of excelent libraries like Lambda and Bind, not to mention other FP libraries like FC++ and newer libraries, like Egg. Now it's time to grab a beer and celebrate :-) Regards, -- Joel de Guzman http://www.boostpro.com http://spirit.sf.net