Re: [Boost-Users] Re: How to use Iterator Adaptors?

--- At Tue, 4 Jun 2002 07:25:05 -0700, Duane Murphy wrote:

--- At Tue, 4 Jun 2002 09:45:12 -0400, David Abrahams wrote:

...

"Duane Murphy" wrote in message news:20020604050249.610@mail.murphyslogic.com...

...

--- At Tue, 4 Jun 2002 00:05:46 -0400, David Abrahams wrote: I dont have any iterator to assign policies to yet.

The policies are supposed to implement the core operations of the iterator using the Base object. You can, of course, stick the neccessary functionality in the Base object and use the default policies, as you are doing, but it seems a little unnatural to me.

...

This is usually a forward iterator if copying is practical given the nature of the API. Basically in the example, the iterator would hold a DIR structure and use the standard DIR APIs to "increment" and dereference the structure as required.

So, what is the "normal" way of creating an iterator out of thin air as it were?

If you have a DIR structure, I would use that as the Base object directly, then write a Policies class which implements the operations on it.

[ Giant light bulb goes on! ]

Now I get it. Thank you very much for this explaination.

Everytime I write an iterator there is almost always some data structure that is required in the iterator for me to use. You have simply "constructed" that part of the iterator through the base template parameter. I have been working way to hard to make this work.

When I first did things this way, I went and wrapped some data structure in all kinds of methods. I see now that I was making too much work for myself. Simply specify the object that is the base and access it directly; no additional objects needed. Treating base as a member variable is acceptable.

Member variable isnt exactly the right terminology. Maybe, using base as a data structure rather than an object would be more correct.

Thank you for this enlightening discussion. I will follow this pattern for my future iterators.

...Duane