Re: [Boost-users] [units] check if quantities are convertible one into the other

The ability to test for a conversion is liable to result in ODR problems. On the other hand, the errors are pretty horrendous right now.

I am not sure how ODR applies here. But I guess a compile time check will have the same limitations are the conversion itself. After all in the same way the constructor quantity1(q2) is defined, so should be an hypothetical is_convertible::static_value. Just a though: for example, can the BOOST_UNITS_DEFINE_CONVERSION_FACTOR add some kind of is_convertible trait at the same time? (I know, it won't be useful for derived conversions).

This is a fairly common problem. Could you file a trac ticket. I'll try to make the error more readable.

sure, https://svn.boost.org/trac/boost/ticket/4988 A better error message will help a lot in this and other contexts but think it is a different issue with respect to the is_convertible feature. Thank you, Alfredo